Death Penalty Defense
Capital defense is team defense.
A death penalty case is two trials in one. The first decides whether the person is guilty. The second decides whether the sentence will be death or life in prison without the possibility of parole. Defending it takes a full team. David has completed extensive death-penalty-defense training and has worked on defense teams in death penalty cases in Fresno, Merced and Kings Counties, alongside experienced lead and associate counsel.
Death Penalty Defense Training
Trained for the cases where everything is at stake.
Since 2024, David has completed seven death-penalty-defense programs put on by the National Association of Criminal Defense Lawyers, the National Association for Public Defense and law schools across the country, returning to two of them for a second year. The training covers telling the client’s life story to the jury, picking a jury, intellectual disability, and defending a death penalty case from the first court date through the sentencing trial.
“Bring Your Own Case” Capital Defense Training
National Association of Criminal Defense Lawyers, Capital Case Initiative · Boise, Idaho
March 12–15, 2024
Bryan R. Shechmeister Death Penalty College
Santa Clara University School of Law · Santa Clara, California
August 1–6, 2024 · August 1–5, 2025
Capital Case Defense Seminar
Monterey, California
February 14–17, 2025
Clarence Darrow/David Baldus Death Penalty College & Intellectual Disability Track
National Association for Public Defense · University of Iowa College of Law
June 3–6, 2025 · June 1–5, 2026
“Making the Case for Life” Capital Defense Training
National Association of Criminal Defense Lawyers · Las Vegas, Nevada
August 27–29, 2025
Summit for Change Mitigation Training
Advancing Real Change · Jacksonville, Florida
April 15–17, 2026
National College of Capital Voir Dire
University of Colorado School of Law · Boulder, Colorado
May 13–16, 2026
Death Penalty Case Experience
On the defense team in death penalty cases.
David has served on the defense team in each of these death penalty cases in Fresno, Merced and Kings Counties, including emergency appeals (“writs”) in the Court of Appeal and the California Supreme Court.
People v. Ger Lee
Fresno County Superior Court · No. F20900024
Related writ proceedings: Lee v. Superior Court, Court of Appeal, Fifth Appellate District, Nos. F084516 and F084547 (mandate) and No. F088934 (prohibition granted); California Supreme Court, No. S290715 (review granted).
People v. Nickey Duane Stane
Fresno County Superior Court · No. F20900679
Related writ proceeding: Stane v. Superior Court (mandate).
People v. Jesus Manuel Salgado
Merced County Superior Court · No. 22CR-05188A
People v. Jaime Osuna
Kings County Superior Court · No. 19CM-1882
Past results do not guarantee the same result in another case.
Coming Soon
Death Penalty Mitigation.
“Mitigation” means the facts about a person’s life, character and background that argue against a death sentence. In a death penalty case, the jury that decides the punishment must be allowed to hear all of it. The United States Supreme Court has ruled that a jury cannot be kept from considering anything about the defendant’s life or character that is offered as a reason for a sentence less than death (Lockett v. Ohio (1978) 438 U.S. 586), and that the defense lawyer has a duty to dig into the client’s background to find that evidence (Wiggins v. Smith (2003) 539 U.S. 510). In California, the jury weighs the factors listed in Penal Code § 190.3, including anything that makes the crime less blameworthy even if it is not a legal excuse for it.
A mitigation investigation is how that evidence is found. National standards for death penalty defense call for a mitigation specialist on every defense team, and the investigation starts at the beginning of the case, not right before the sentencing trial. What it turns up is used to ask the prosecutor not to seek death, in plea negotiations, and as the heart of the defense if the case goes to a sentencing trial.
A MITIGATION INVESTIGATION INCLUDES
- Putting together the person’s complete life history from birth, medical, school, work, military, juvenile and mental health records
- In-person interviews with family members, teachers, coaches, employers and others who have known the person across a lifetime
- Documenting the trauma, abuse, neglect, poverty, violence, head injuries and other experiences that shaped the person
- Spotting signs of intellectual disability, mental illness or brain injury and bringing in experts to evaluate them; a person with an intellectual disability cannot be sentenced to death (Atkins v. Virginia (2002) 536 U.S. 304; Penal Code § 1376)
- Understanding the person’s cultural, family and community history, including immigration and language
- Presenting that history through witnesses and experts so the jury sees the whole person, not just the crime
More information about this office’s mitigation work is coming soon.