Criminal Street Gang Charges

A gang allegation can add more time than the crime itself.

Penal Code § 186.22 lets the prosecution charge gang membership as its own crime and add years, or a life term, to almost any felony by claiming it was done for a gang. David defends gang cases and fights gang allegations in Fresno and the Central Valley, where they are filed more often than almost anywhere in the state.

A closed courtroom door in a quiet courthouse hallway

What the Law Says

The gang law works three ways, and the rules for proving it changed in 2022.

California’s gang law is the STEP Act, Penal Code § 186.22. It is used in three different ways, and a single case can involve all three.

Gang participation as its own crime

Active participation in a criminal street gang (Penal Code § 186.22(a)) is a separate charge. The prosecution has to prove the person was an active member of a gang, knew the gang’s members commit crimes, and personally helped commit a felony with other gang members. It can be filed as a misdemeanor or a felony, and as a felony it carries 16 months, 2 or 3 years.

The gang enhancement

The gang enhancement (Penal Code § 186.22(b)) is the part that does the most damage. It is attached to another felony — an assault, a robbery, a shooting, a drug sale — on the claim that the crime was committed for the benefit of a gang, at a gang’s direction, or together with gang members, and with the intent to help the gang’s criminal activity. It adds 2, 3 or 4 years to an ordinary felony, 5 years to a serious felony, and 10 years to a violent felony. For some crimes, such as home-invasion robbery, carjacking or shooting at a house or a car, it turns the sentence into life. A gang enhancement also makes the underlying felony a strike.

Gang allegations bring other laws with them. When someone in the group used a gun, the gang gun enhancement (Penal Code § 12022.53(e)) can add 10, 20 or 25 years to life to a person who never touched the weapon. A killing “to further the activities” of a gang is a special circumstance (Penal Code § 190.2(a)(22)) that makes a murder punishable by life without parole or death.

Gang registration and injunctions

Anyone convicted of a gang crime or enhancement has to register with the police as a gang member (Penal Code § 186.30) for five years, and failing to register is a new crime. In some cities a civil gang injunction makes ordinary conduct — being in a neighborhood with certain people, wearing certain clothes — a violation that can bring jail time.

What changed in 2022

A 2022 law (Assembly Bill 333) rewrote much of § 186.22 because gang allegations were being proven with little more than tattoos, clothing and an officer’s opinion. The prosecution now has to prove that the gang’s members collectively engage in a pattern of crime, using at least two earlier crimes committed by members within three years of each other and within three years of the new charge, and the new charge itself cannot be one of them. The benefit to the gang has to be more than reputation — something concrete, like money, territory or silencing a witness. Several lesser crimes, such as vandalism and looting, no longer count as gang crimes at all. And under a new Penal Code § 1109, the defense can demand that the gang allegation be tried separately, after the jury decides the underlying charge, so that gang evidence does not poison the jury’s view of the crime itself. These changes apply to many older cases too, which has reopened a number of convictions on appeal and in resentencing.

How the Office Defends These Cases

The gang allegation is attacked as its own case, because it is one.

  1. Splitting the trial

    Under Penal Code § 1109 the defense asks that the gang allegation be tried separately, after the jury has decided the underlying charge. Without that split, jurors hear about gangs before they hear about the crime.

  2. Testing the “gang” itself

    The prosecution has to prove a real organization with members who collectively commit crimes. The defense checks each earlier crime the prosecution relies on — the dates, who committed it, and whether it counts under the 2022 law.

  3. Benefit and intent

    The claim that the crime was done for the gang, and that the client meant to help the gang, is often based on nothing more than who was present. The defense demands proof of a concrete benefit, not reputation.

  4. The gang expert

    Gang cases are built on a police officer testifying as an expert. The defense examines what the officer actually knows, where the information came from, and what the law allows an expert to repeat. A great deal of this testimony is secondhand and can be kept out.

  5. Tattoos, clothing and social media

    Photos, posts, lyrics and clothing are offered as proof of membership. The defense puts them in context and keeps the jury focused on what the client did, not how he looks or who his friends are.

  6. Striking the enhancement

    Even when a gang allegation is found true, the court has the power to strike it or to refuse to impose it. The defense builds the case for that from the client’s history and the facts of the offense.

  7. Older convictions

    For clients already serving time on a gang enhancement, the 2022 changes may apply. The defense reviews the record and pursues an appeal, a writ or a resentencing petition where they do.