Human Trafficking Defense

A trafficking charge carries a decade or more. It deserves a defense built with care.

Human trafficking is among the most heavily punished crimes in California, and the label alone can end careers and families. These cases are often built on the word of a single witness and on text messages and online ads read in the worst possible light. David defends human trafficking cases in state court in Fresno and the Central Valley.

A motel walkway at night

What the Law Says

The charge covers forced labor and commercial sex, and the sentences are severe.

California’s human trafficking law, Penal Code § 236.1, has three parts. Depriving someone of their liberty in order to obtain forced labor or services carries 5, 8 or 12 years in prison. Depriving someone of their liberty in order to commit pimping, pandering, prostitution-related crimes or child pornography offenses carries 8, 14 or 20 years. Causing or persuading a minor to engage in a commercial sex act carries 5, 8 or 12 years, or 15 years to life if force, fear, fraud or coercion is used. Fines can reach $500,000, and a conviction requires lifetime sex offender registration.

For a minor, the prosecution does not have to prove force or that the accused knew the minor’s age — a mistaken belief that the person was an adult is not a defense. For an adult, the prosecution must prove that the person’s liberty was actually restrained by force, fear, fraud, deceit, coercion, violence, duress or threats. The line between a trafficking charge and the lesser charges of pimping and pandering often comes down to that element, and to how the evidence of “coercion” is read.

These cases frequently arise from online advertisements, hotel records, phone extractions and the statements of a complaining witness who may have strong reasons — including immigration relief and avoiding her own charges — to describe the relationship in a particular way. The same conduct may also be charged in federal court under 18 U.S.C. § 1591, where the sentences are longer still.

How the Office Defends These Cases

The evidence is examined, not assumed.

  1. Every message in context

    Trafficking cases are often built on thousands of text messages and ads. The defense reviews all of them, not the handful the prosecution selects, because context changes meaning.

  2. The complaining witness

    The defense investigates the witness’s own statements over time, the benefits offered for cooperation, and any inconsistencies, and confronts them at the preliminary hearing and at trial.

  3. Force, fear and coercion

    For an adult, the prosecution must prove the person’s liberty was actually restrained. Where the evidence shows a relationship without coercion, the charge may not fit — and the difference is many years.

  4. Experts

    Digital forensics experts examine phone and account data; where mental health or the client’s own history of exploitation is relevant, those experts are brought in too.

  5. Collateral consequences

    A trafficking conviction brings lifetime sex offender registration, deportation for non-citizens, and the loss of property the government says was connected to the crime. Those consequences are part of every decision about how to resolve the case.

  6. Federal exposure

    When a case could be charged federally, the defense plans for that from the start. David is admitted in the U.S. District Court for the Eastern District of California.