Welfare Fraud Defense

Most welfare fraud cases start long before any charge is filed.

Welfare fraud cases — CalFresh, CalWORKs, Medi-Cal and housing benefits — usually begin with a letter from the county or a visit from a fraud investigator, months before a prosecutor is involved. What happens in that window often decides whether the case is handled as an overpayment or as a felony. David represents people at every stage, from the first interview request through trial.

Benefits paperwork, reading glasses and a coffee mug on a kitchen table

What the Law Says

An overpayment becomes a crime when the county says it was intentional.

The main welfare fraud statute is Welfare and Institutions Code § 10980. Making a false statement or failing to report a change — income, a household member, a job — in order to get or keep benefits is a misdemeanor, or a felony if the benefits obtained were worth more than $950, punishable by 16 months, 2 or 3 years. Using or transferring CalFresh benefits improperly is a separate offense under the same section. The same conduct is often also charged as perjury on a benefits application (Penal Code § 118, a felony) and as grand theft (Penal Code § 487).

Before any criminal charge, the county’s fraud unit usually asks for an interview and may schedule an “Intentional Program Violation” hearing — the county’s own hearing on whether you broke the rules on purpose. Statements made at that stage are used in the criminal case, and an IPV finding can disqualify a person from benefits for a year, two years, or permanently, in addition to repayment. People often agree to repayment and sign admissions without a lawyer, not realizing the admission can become the heart of a felony case.

The prosecution has to prove the person knew the statement was false or knew about the change and intentionally failed to report it. Honest confusion about complicated reporting rules, a change the person believed had been reported, or income that did not actually have to be reported is not fraud.

How the Office Defends These Cases

Early is better. Getting involved before charges are filed changes the options.

  1. Before the interview

    If the county has asked for an interview, the time to call is before it happens. David advises whether to attend, prepares the client, and attends when that is the right choice.

  2. Repayment and resolution without charges

    In many cases a repayment agreement reached early, with the county or the District Attorney’s welfare fraud unit, resolves the matter without a criminal filing.

  3. Intent

    The prosecution must prove the person knew the statement was false or deliberately hid a change. Reporting rules are complicated, and the defense develops the evidence of what the client actually understood and reported.

  4. The county’s numbers

    The amount of the alleged overpayment determines whether the case is a misdemeanor or a felony and how much restitution is claimed. The county’s calculation is checked against the actual eligibility rules, and it is often wrong.

  5. Diversion and reduction

    Where charges are filed, diversion, reduction to a misdemeanor, and dismissal after restitution are all pursued where available.

  6. Immigration and benefits consequences

    A fraud conviction can affect immigration status and future eligibility for benefits. Those consequences are weighed in every resolution.