DUI Defense
A DUI is two cases at once: court and the DMV.
A DUI arrest starts a criminal case in court and a separate fight over your driver’s license at the DMV, and the DMV clock runs out in 10 days. David defends DUI cases in Fresno and the Central Valley, from a first offense to felony DUI, DUI with injury, vehicular manslaughter and Watson murder.

What the Law Says
The penalty depends on your record, on whether anyone was hurt, and on the 10-year window.
California charges DUI two ways at the same time: driving while impaired by alcohol or drugs (Vehicle Code § 23152(a)), and driving with a blood-alcohol level of 0.08 percent or more (Vehicle Code § 23152(b)). Most people are charged with both. For a commercial driver the limit is 0.04, and for a driver under 21 any measurable alcohol brings a separate license penalty.
A first DUI
A first DUI with no one hurt is a misdemeanor. It usually means probation for three to five years, fines and fees that add up to several thousand dollars, a DUI class of three to nine months, a license suspension, and in many counties an ignition interlock device on your car. Jail is possible but is often avoided on a first offense.
Prior DUIs and the 10-year window
Earlier DUI convictions make it worse. The law looks back 10 years from the date of the new arrest, and every DUI or “wet reckless” conviction inside that window counts, including convictions from other states. A second DUI in 10 years means a minimum of 96 hours in jail and up to a year, an 18-month class and a longer suspension. A third means at least 120 days in jail, a 30-month class, and the loss of the license for three years. A fourth DUI within 10 years is a felony (Vehicle Code § 23550), carrying 16 months, 2 or 3 years in prison. A DUI is also a felony, no matter how many priors, if the driver has ever been convicted of felony DUI or of injuring or killing someone while driving drunk (Vehicle Code § 23550.5).
DUI with injury
DUI with injury (Vehicle Code § 23153) is charged when someone other than the driver was hurt in a crash and the prosecution says the drunk driving, plus some other driving mistake, caused it. It can be filed as a misdemeanor or a felony depending on how badly the person was hurt and the driver’s record. As a felony it carries 16 months, 2 or 3 years, and if the injury was serious the prosecution adds a great-bodily-injury allegation that adds 3 more years and makes the conviction a strike.
When someone dies in a DUI crash
When someone dies in a DUI crash, the charge is no longer a DUI. Vehicular manslaughter while intoxicated (Penal Code § 191.5(b)) is a DUI crash that killed someone through ordinary carelessness. It can be filed as a misdemeanor or a felony; as a felony it carries 16 months, 2 or 4 years. Gross vehicular manslaughter while intoxicated (Penal Code § 191.5(a)) is the same crash where the prosecution says the driving was not just careless but reckless to a degree that showed no regard for human life — very high speed, running lights, driving the wrong way. It is always a felony and carries 4, 6 or 10 years, and 15 years to life if the driver has earlier DUI convictions. A “Watson” murder is a second-degree murder charge for a deadly DUI crash. It comes from a court case called People v. Watson, and it is brought when the prosecution says the driver already knew how dangerous drunk driving was — usually because of an earlier DUI conviction, where the judge reads a warning that a future deadly crash can be charged as murder — and drove drunk anyway. It carries 15 years to life. The line between these three charges is drawn by how the driving is described and by what the driver knew, which is why the crash reconstruction, the toxicology and the record of any earlier warning matter so much. David handles these cases as homicide cases, with the team described on the Homicide Defense page.
The DMV case is separate
The DMV case is separate. When you are arrested the officer takes your license and gives you a pink notice. That notice is a temporary license for 30 days, and it is also your only warning: you have 10 days from the arrest to ask the DMV for a hearing. If no hearing is requested, the suspension starts automatically, whatever happens in court. Refusing the breath or blood test brings its own, longer suspension, at least a year, even if the criminal case is later dismissed.
How the Office Defends These Cases
Every DUI case is tested at the stop, at the test, and at the DMV.
The DMV hearing, first
David requests the DMV hearing inside the 10-day window, which keeps you driving while the case goes on, and uses the hearing to question the officer under oath before the criminal case gets going.
The stop
The police need a legal reason to pull you over. If the stop was bad, the evidence that came from it can be kept out under Penal Code § 1538.5, and the case often ends there.
The field tests and the arrest
Roadside balance tests are graded by the officer, often on a dark shoulder with traffic going by. The body-camera video is reviewed against what the report claims, and the defense looks at whether there was enough to arrest at all.
The breath or blood test
Breath machines have to be calibrated and run correctly; blood samples have to be drawn, stored and tested the right way. The defense gets the maintenance and lab records and, when it matters, hires its own toxicologist. Alcohol absorbed after driving, medical conditions and rising blood alcohol can all put the number in doubt.
Priors and the 10-year window
Whether an old DUI counts depends on dates and on whether that earlier conviction was valid. The defense checks each prior, because knocking one out can turn a felony back into a misdemeanor.
Injury cases
In a DUI-with-injury case the prosecution has to prove the drunk driving actually caused the crash. Crash reconstruction, the other driver’s conduct and the medical records are all examined before anyone accepts the prosecution’s version.
Fatal crashes
In a manslaughter or Watson murder case the defense works from the physical evidence: an independent crash reconstruction, the timing and handling of the blood draw, the other driver’s conduct, and exactly what warning the client was given at any earlier DUI and whether it was understood. Those facts decide whether the case is murder, gross manslaughter, ordinary manslaughter, or not the client’s fault.
Limiting the damage
When a case cannot be dismissed, the defense works for a reduced charge such as wet reckless, for the least time in custody, for programs instead of jail, and for a result that can be cleared from the record later.