Homicide Defense

Murder and manslaughter charges demand a full defense team.

A homicide charge is the most serious case in the criminal courts. The prosecution has unlimited resources, and the sentence can be life. David defends murder and manslaughter cases in Fresno and the Central Valley, with a team of investigators and experts behind him.

A chalk outline on a wet street at night

What the Law Says

Not every killing is murder. The charge depends on what the person intended and why.

California law separates homicide into several crimes, and the difference between them can be decades of prison time. Murder (Penal Code § 187) is an unlawful killing with “malice” — meaning the person intended to kill, or acted knowing the conduct was dangerous to human life. First-degree murder is a killing that was planned, or committed during certain felonies such as robbery or burglary, and carries 25 years to life. Second-degree murder carries 15 years to life. When the prosecution alleges a “special circumstance” — more than one victim, murder during a robbery, or a gang killing, for example — the possible sentence becomes life without parole or death.

Voluntary manslaughter (Penal Code § 192(a)) is a killing in the heat of passion after serious provocation, or in an honest but unreasonable belief that deadly force was needed in self-defense. It carries 3, 6 or 11 years. Involuntary manslaughter (Penal Code § 192(b)) is a killing without intent to kill, through criminal negligence, and carries 2, 3 or 4 years. Vehicular manslaughter (Penal Code § 192(c)) covers deaths caused by negligent driving when alcohol or drugs were not involved.

When the driver was under the influence, the charge is different and heavier. Vehicular manslaughter while intoxicated (Penal Code § 191.5(b)) is a DUI crash that killed someone through ordinary carelessness. It can be filed as a misdemeanor or a felony; as a felony it carries 16 months, 2 or 4 years. Gross vehicular manslaughter while intoxicated (Penal Code § 191.5(a)) is the same crash where the prosecution says the driving was not just careless but reckless to a degree that showed no regard for human life — very high speed, running lights, driving the wrong way. It is always a felony and carries 4, 6 or 10 years. If the driver has earlier DUI convictions, the sentence for the gross version becomes 15 years to life, and the prosecution may charge Watson murder instead, as explained next. The line between these charges, and between them and murder, is drawn by how the driving is described, which is why the crash reconstruction and the toxicology matter so much.

Two kinds of murder charges are becoming common in Fresno County even though no one meant to kill anyone. A “Watson” murder is a second-degree murder charge for a deadly DUI crash. It comes from a court case called People v. Watson, and it is brought when the prosecution says the driver already knew how dangerous drunk driving was — usually because of an earlier DUI conviction, where the judge reads a warning that a future deadly crash can be charged as murder — and drove drunk anyway. A fentanyl murder is the same theory applied to drugs: a person who sold or handed someone fentanyl that caused a fatal overdose is charged with second-degree murder on the claim that they knew the drug could kill and provided it anyway, often after a warning given at an earlier drug conviction. Both carry 15 years to life. In both, the real fight is over what the person actually knew and understood at the time, which is a very different question from whether the death happened.

A killing in lawful self-defense or defense of another person is not a crime at all. Whether the case is murder, manslaughter or no crime often turns on facts that take a careful investigation to establish: who started the confrontation, what the person knew and feared in the moment, and what the physical evidence shows about how it happened.

How the Office Defends These Cases

A homicide case is built, not argued.

  1. A defense team from day one

    David believes a homicide case needs a team. He works with defense investigators and with experts in forensic pathology, crime-scene reconstruction, use of force, mental health and gangs, and he asks the court to pay for them when the client cannot.

  2. An independent investigation

    Witnesses are found and interviewed, video is collected before it is erased, and the physical evidence is reviewed by the defense’s own experts rather than taken on the prosecution’s word.

  3. Self-defense and heat of passion

    Many homicide cases turn on what the person believed and feared in the moment. The defense develops that evidence from the start, because it can mean the difference between murder, manslaughter and no crime.

  4. Watson and fentanyl murder cases

    These charges rest on proving the person knew the risk to human life and ignored it. The defense examines what warnings were actually given and understood, what the person knew about the drug or their own condition, the toxicology and the cause of death, and whether the evidence supports murder at all or at most manslaughter or a drug charge.

  5. The preliminary hearing

    In a murder case the preliminary hearing is the first full test of the prosecution’s evidence, and the record made there shapes everything after it, including any writ to the Court of Appeal.

  6. Special circumstances and the death penalty

    When the prosecution alleges special circumstances, the case may become a capital case. David has completed extensive death-penalty-defense training and has served on defense teams in capital cases in Fresno, Merced and Kings Counties.

  7. Mitigation at every stage

    The client’s life history — trauma, mental health, youth — is developed early. It can shape charging decisions, plea negotiations and sentencing, not just a penalty trial.