Domestic Violence Defense

An argument at home can become a criminal case in minutes.

Once police are called to a home, someone is usually arrested, and the case moves forward even if the other person wants it dropped. A domestic violence charge brings a protective order, the loss of gun rights, and a conviction that affects jobs, custody and immigration for years. David defends domestic violence cases in Fresno and the Central Valley.

The front porch of a small house at night, porch light on

What the Law Says

The prosecutor, not the other person, decides whether the case goes forward.

California charges domestic violence under several different laws. Domestic battery (Penal Code § 243(e)(1)) is any unwanted, offensive touching of a spouse, partner, former partner, or the other parent of your child — a push or a grab is enough — and it is a misdemeanor punishable by up to a year in jail. Corporal injury to a spouse or partner (Penal Code § 273.5) requires a visible injury, even a minor one, and can be charged as a misdemeanor or a felony carrying 2, 3 or 4 years in prison. Prior convictions raise the penalties.

Other charges often filed alongside these include criminal threats (Penal Code § 422), violating a protective order (Penal Code § 273.6), child endangerment (Penal Code § 273a), stalking (Penal Code § 646.9), and damaging a phone to stop a call for help (Penal Code § 591.5). Any conviction for domestic violence, even a misdemeanor, requires a year-long batterer’s treatment program, a ten-year ban on owning a gun under California law and a lifetime ban under federal law, and usually a criminal protective order that can keep you out of your own home.

Once police are called, the decision to prosecute belongs to the District Attorney, not to the person who called. Prosecutors routinely go forward when the other person recants or refuses to testify, using the 911 call, body-camera video, photos and statements made that night. These cases turn on what the evidence from that night actually shows — who was the aggressor, whether there was an injury, and whether the person acted in self-defense.

How the Office Defends These Cases

The evidence from that night decides the case.

  1. The protective order

    At the first court date the judge usually issues a criminal protective order. David asks for the version that allows peaceful contact and lets the client stay in the home when the facts support it.

  2. What the recordings show

    The 911 call and the officers’ body-camera video are obtained and reviewed in full. They often show a different picture than the police report — including who called, who was injured, and who was calm.

  3. Self-defense and who started it

    Many domestic violence arrests follow a mutual fight or an act of self-defense. The defense develops that evidence from the start, including the other person’s injuries, history and statements.

  4. When the other person does not want to go forward

    A recanting witness does not end the case, but it changes it. David handles these situations carefully, within the rules, so that the client is protected and the witness is not pressured.

  5. Reductions and alternatives

    Where the evidence allows, the defense pursues dismissal, reduction to a charge that is not domestic violence, or a resolution that avoids the gun ban, the treatment program and the immigration consequences.

  6. Custody and immigration

    A domestic violence conviction affects custody of children and can lead to deportation. Those consequences are part of every decision about how to resolve the case.