Sexual Assault Defense

An accusation is not evidence. These cases are won on the details.

Sexual assault charges — rape, sodomy, oral copulation by force, sexual penetration and lewd acts with a child — carry some of the longest sentences in California law and lifetime registration. They are also cases that often come down to one person’s word against another’s, sometimes years after the fact. David defends sexual assault cases in Fresno and the Central Valley with a team approach and experienced experts.

A closed courtroom door in a quiet courthouse hallway

What the Law Says

The sentences are measured in decades, and consent is usually the question.

Rape (Penal Code § 261) is sexual intercourse without consent, accomplished by force, fear, threats, or with a person who is unconscious, too intoxicated to consent, or unable to consent because of a disability. It carries 3, 6 or 8 years, and more when the victim is a minor or when there are multiple victims or aggravating circumstances under the “One Strike” law (Penal Code § 667.61), which can require a sentence of 15 or 25 years to life. Sodomy (§ 286), oral copulation (§ 287) and sexual penetration (§ 289) by force carry the same ranges.

Lewd acts with a child under 14 (Penal Code § 288) carries 3, 6 or 8 years, and 5, 8 or 10 years when force is used; continuous sexual abuse of a child (§ 288.5) carries 6, 12 or 16 years. Unlawful sexual intercourse with a minor (§ 261.5, “statutory rape”) is a misdemeanor or a felony depending on the ages involved. Nearly all of these convictions require lifetime sex offender registration under Penal Code § 290, and many are strikes.

In adult cases the central question is almost always consent, and the evidence is text messages, witnesses to the hours before and after, and the complaining witness’s own statements over time. In child cases the evidence is often a recorded interview of the child by a specially trained interviewer, and the defense needs experts who can evaluate how those interviews were done. The time limits for filing many of these charges have been extended or removed, so charges can be filed years or decades later.

How the Office Defends These Cases

A careful investigation, the right experts, and no shortcuts.

  1. The full story of the accusation

    When, how and to whom the accusation was first made, how it changed, and what else was happening in the accuser’s life are investigated thoroughly and respectfully.

  2. Digital evidence

    Text messages, social media and location data from the hours and days around the alleged event frequently tell a different story than the police report. The defense obtains all of it.

  3. Experts

    David regularly works with experts in sexual assault cases, including experts who evaluate how a child was interviewed, DNA and drug-and-alcohol testing experts, and psychologists. He asks the court to fund them when the client cannot.

  4. Pretext calls and police interviews

    Many of these cases include a “pretext call” — a call the accuser makes to the client, recorded by police, hoping to get an admission — and a police interview of the client. Both are examined for coercion and for what they actually show.

  5. The preliminary hearing and writs

    The preliminary hearing is used to test the evidence under oath, and rulings that let the case go forward on insufficient evidence are challenged by writ in the Court of Appeal.

  6. Registration and the One Strike law

    Because registration and life sentences are at stake, every charging decision and plea offer is examined for its effect on registration, strikes and when the person could be released.