Resentencing & Sentencing Mitigation

A sentence is not always the last word.

At sentencing, the judge decides how much of the possible punishment to impose. Later, many sentences can be reopened under laws that have changed in recent years. David prepares sentencing cases that tell the client’s whole story, and he brings requests to reopen and reduce old sentences in Fresno and the Central Valley.

A judge’s bench with a gavel and the California seal

How These Cases Work

California law now gives real weight to the facts in a person’s favor.

At sentencing, the judge weighs the facts that make the crime worse against the facts that call for a lighter sentence. California law now gives real weight to the second group. In many cases, the judge must start from the lowest sentence when childhood trauma, youth or past abuse played a part in the offense (Penal Code § 1170(b)(6)), and must give great weight to certain facts in a person’s favor when deciding whether to remove an add-on penalty (Penal Code § 1385(c)). Making that case takes records, interviews and expert evaluations, put together in a written sentencing brief for the judge.

California sentencing law has changed a great deal in recent years. Judges now have more power to remove add-on penalties, and many sentences handed down under the old rules can be reopened and reconsidered. People who were sentenced years ago may be able to ask for a new sentencing hearing and not know it.

It may also be possible to ask the court to set aside a guilty plea that was entered without a full understanding of what it meant, or to reduce a felony to a misdemeanor.

How the Office Defends These Cases

The judge should know the whole person, not just the charge.

  1. The sentencing brief

    A written brief tells the judge who the client is, what led to the offense, and why a lower sentence is the right one. David writes these for his own clients and for other lawyers.

  2. Mitigation evidence

    Records, interviews with family and others, and expert evaluations document the client’s history — childhood trauma, mental health, youth — in the form the law now requires judges to weigh.

  3. Striking enhancements

    Add-on penalties can add years. The court now has the power to remove them, and David makes that request with the evidence the law calls for.

  4. Reopening old sentences

    Many sentences imposed under older rules can be recalled and reconsidered. David reviews old cases for eligibility and files the petition.

  5. Setting aside a plea

    When a plea was entered without a full understanding of what it meant, the court can be asked to set it aside.

  6. Felony to misdemeanor

    Certain felonies can be reduced to misdemeanors under Penal Code § 17(b), which restores rights and clears the way to having the conviction dismissed from the record.